First off, I LOVE IT! I've had it for 5 weeks now, playing every day. When you run your fingers over the paddle, it doesn't feel as gritty as i was expecting. I still do categorize it as elite spin.
I came from a Selkirk Invikta Power Air. My new Holbrook paddle does NOT have the same power. The Selkirk is "poppier". I still like the Aero Pro Metallic better. It does feel plush. I can feel the ball on the paddle. Real obvious to me is an inside out at the kitchen. This paddle gives me the confidence for the touch shots. I don't have as much power, but I can shape the serves and shots better with this paddle. Yesterday I demo'd 2 very expensive Joola paddles. Felt great to pick this paddle up again.